Final Statement of the Workshop on Quantum Science and Technology: Recent advances and new perspectives

2023
Statement
12 December

Final Statement of the Workshop on Quantum Science and Technology

Recent advances and new perspectives

Final Statement of the Workshop on Quantum Science and Technology
Photo: Gabriella C. Marino

Quantum science is a remarkable achievement of the human mind, and it has profound implications for our understanding of nature. As we approach the centenary of its birth, we can reflect on its past, present and future challenges and opportunities.

Quantum science was developed to explain the fundamental properties of matter, following the footsteps of previous scientific revolutions. Like any other science, it started as a theoretical endeavor, subject to questions and criticism, and eventually became a source of innovation and commercial exploration.

Quantum science has contributed to the advancement of electronics, materials science, and chemistry, among other fields. More recently, quantum phenomena have been explored as potential resources for communication and computation. These possibilities are especially relevant in the age of information and technology, and they have attracted a lot of attention, popularity and investment. The benefits of these new technologies are yet to be fully realized and understood.

The topic of quantum science is still open to debate and inquiry, and it is still far from being settled or exhausted. The more than 50 presentations at this conference of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences provided us with new insights and recommendations on this fascinating topic.

1 – Lessons from the past

Quantum concepts have faced criticism and skepticism since their inception. However, the relentless efforts and interactions of scientists have led to amazing discoveries. Scientists overcame the opposition and challenges with resilience and determination, paving the way for great breakthroughs. One of the most important lessons from the history of quantum science is the value of investing in intellect and basic research, which can lead to great developments. Basic science becomes relevant science, advancing not only knowledge but also providing solutions to real world problems.

2 – The status in the present

Quantum science has led to enormous advances

... Read all

Quantum science is a remarkable achievement of the human mind, and it has profound implications for our understanding of nature. As we approach the centenary of its birth, we can reflect on its past, present and future challenges and opportunities.

Quantum science was developed to explain the fundamental properties of matter, following the footsteps of previous scientific revolutions. Like any other science, it started as a theoretical endeavor, subject to questions and criticism, and eventually became a source of innovation and commercial exploration.

Quantum science has contributed to the advancement of electronics, materials science, and chemistry, among other fields. More recently, quantum phenomena have been explored as potential resources for communication and computation. These possibilities are especially relevant in the age of information and technology, and they have attracted a lot of attention, popularity and investment. The benefits of these new technologies are yet to be fully realized and understood.

The topic of quantum science is still open to debate and inquiry, and it is still far from being settled or exhausted. The more than 50 presentations at this conference of the Pontifical Academy of Sciences provided us with new insights and recommendations on this fascinating topic.

1 – Lessons from the past

Quantum concepts have faced criticism and skepticism since their inception. However, the relentless efforts and interactions of scientists have led to amazing discoveries. Scientists overcame the opposition and challenges with resilience and determination, paving the way for great breakthroughs. One of the most important lessons from the history of quantum science is the value of investing in intellect and basic research, which can lead to great developments. Basic science becomes relevant science, advancing not only knowledge but also providing solutions to real world problems.

2 – The status in the present

Quantum science has led to enormous advances in various fields, such as electronics, pharmaceuticals and materials science, and – very importantly – quantum physics-based measurement. Without the foundations of quantum mechanics, we would not be witnessing the so-called quantum revolution, which is transforming communications, computation, control systems and the production of new molecules to treat specific diseases.

Quantum science has opened up a new world, where we can observe and manipulate atoms and molecules, and understand that phenomena such as superfluidity, superconductivity and other super-properties are manifestations of the same quantum principles. Quantum science has also allowed the creation of quantum simulators, which can provide experimental solutions to problems that are otherwise intractable. As the saying goes: if we can formulate the problem and we do not have its solution, nature will tell us the answer through experiments.

Quantum technology has also made possible the use of quantum properties for storing and processing information with unprecedented accuracy and speed. These properties are the basis of quantum computing, which is a rapidly developing field with many challenges and opportunities. Some researchers are focusing on demonstrating the principles of quantum computing, while others are working on scaling up the operations and processors to achieve a universal quantum computer.

Quantum technology also offers the possibility of creating quantum sensors, which can enhance the detection and measurement of various physical quantities, such as magnetic fields, gravity acceleration medicine, and detection of chemical reactions inside cells. Quantum technology is advancing fast, and many experts think that we may witness the second quantum revolution.

Many investors are seizing the opportunities and supporting companies that are dedicated to quantum science and technology. The future of quantum science and technology depends on the outcomes of the current research and development efforts.

3 – Future perspectives

Quantum science and technology is an exciting field that attracts many young researchers and challenges many technical barriers. One of the main goals is to achieve scalable quantum computing, which could offer unprecedented “quantum processing power” for solving complex problems. Quantum technologies may result even in the discovery of physics beyond established models, providing a glimpse into new laws of nature.

However, there are still many obstacles to overcome, such as the correction of natural errors that occur during quantum processing. The current progress is promising, but it is not clear whether quantum computers will become a reality or a niche tool for some problems in the near future.

Quantum communication, based on photons prepared in entangled states, offers security and privacy for data transmission through quantum cryptography. This technology can enhance digital security and prevent tampering. Quantum communication is already a reality, but it needs to become more accessible and affordable.

Quantum sensors, which can measure magnetic and gravitational fields with high precision, have many potential applications, such as exploring natural resources, oil, and carrying out pest control in crops. Quantum sensors can also help in detecting diseases at early stages, which are difficult to diagnose with conventional methods. Quantum sensors of different types can improve the detection of pests in crops and monitor pollution.

With the involvement of large companies in quantum applications, the number of startups may decrease. The large corporations may have different interests and strategies, such as providing evidence for the feasibility of quantum technologies or delaying their commercialization.

4 – Potential impact of quantum technologies on society

Quantum technologies, such as quantum sensors and quantum telecommunication, have the potential to improve the state of the art of clinical diagnosis and health care for humans, animals, and plants.

For example, precision gravitometers can help in finding and managing water resources, which are scarce in several regions of the planet, and also in detecting and preventing natural disasters such as earthquakes and emerging storms or floods.

Sensors can also enhance agriculture by combining with artificial intelligence to optimize food production, food distribution systems, and reduce environmental impact.

Quantum computing, if successfully implemented, may assist in the development of renewable energies and materials, and possibly in monitoring and mitigating climate change and its effects.  

5- Concerns and recommendations to achieve quantum opportunities

  1. Support basic sciences: Quantum physics is still at a stage of basic science and continues to generate new basic insights. It remains important to support basic research and foster public investment in international partnerships in this field.
  2. Quantum opportunities must be accessible and inclusive for all: That is not assured. Like any new technology that arrives, its cost can be prohibitive for low-income countries. This could further increase inequalities between societies. It is necessary to take due care so that all societies are prepared to know how to deal with and use the new quantum technologies. International science partnerships and sharing knowledge are needed for that as well.
  3. Public goods focus: Care must be taken so that narrow economic interests do not outweigh broader societal interests and that – from the outset – quantum opportunities for public goods, planetary health and people’s wellbeing are to be prioritized. As developments so far are restricted to a few countries, it is necessary that open dissemination initiatives, both to explain the development of this branch of science and to facilitate the participation of many, are supported by the main participants, and endorsed by scientific associations of international scope.
  4. Secure communication: Given that fault-tolerant quantum computers could break our current public key infrastructure essential to secure communications and much modern financial activities that are either online or the result of automated electronic transactions, it is essential to encourage the replacement of the current public key infrastructure with quantum resistant cryptography once it is standardized.
  5. Science education and media: As quantum concepts are becoming present in several technologies, it is advisable to introduce appropriate standards and principles into basic science education such as in high schools and special colleges. Scientific dissemination in the media must be intensified too, to demonstrate that these new concepts are in accordance with nature and that they are now being mastered for the benefit of his own progress.
  6. Innovation ecosystems: The quantum evolution needs a conducive innovation ecosystem to serve people and planet. As quantum knowledge reaches the market and society, it is necessary to think about the appropriate division of responsibilities. Who will do what, and who controls the ecosystem of quantum technologies as a whole? The main participants in this development, namely scientists, companies, and society itself, must develop concepts for access and responsibilities.
  7. Attention to solution orientation: Quantum computing offers transformative potential to advance solutions for some of society’s most pressing issues, such as climate change, health, hunger. But the existence of qubits alone will not deliver these results. Rather, industry, governments, and academia must act in concert to tackle the impact, use, and access issues this new technology presents.
  8. Cooperation rather than competition: We have reached a point where we understand how to mitigate quantum computing’s attendant security risks; we must now channel it toward societally-positive applications. Instead of a nationalistic competition of first achievers, deep partnership and proactive collaboration will enable us to effectively harness the full power of this profound new technology. Therefore, we endorse a global, open and equitable access to quantum resources, to inclusively unleash the power of quantum technologies so that the whole world may contribute to and benefit from quantum technologies.
Read Less

Signatories

Prof. Vanderlei Bagnato
PAS Academician and conference Co-Chair
Professor University of São Paulo and Texas A&M
Brazil

Prof. William Phillips
PAS Academician and conference Co-Chair
JQI Fellow Joint Quantum Institute
USA

Prof. Joachim von Braun
PAS President
Professor for Economic and Technological Change, Bonn University
Germany

Cardinal Peter Turkson
PAS Chancellor
The Vatican

Conference participants

Dr. Aleksey Akimov
Principal Investigator Russian Quantum Center
Russia

Prof. Carlo F. Barenghi
Professor
Newcastle University
UK

Prof. Immanuel Bloch
Scientific Director
Max Planck Institute of Quantum Optics
Germany

Dr. Sergio Boixo
Principal Scientist, Quantum Computing Google
USA

Prof. Philippe Bouyer
Professor
Univ. of Amsterdam and Technical Univ. Eindhoven
The Netherlands

Prof. Philip Bucksbaum
Professor
Stanford University
USA

Prof. Tommaso Calarco
Director of the Institute of Quantum Control Forschungszentrum Jülich
Germany

Prof. Paola Cappellaro
Ford Professor of Nuclear Science and Engineering, Professor of Physics
Director, Quantum@MIT, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
USA

Prof. Dr. Ignacio Cirac
Director of Theory Division
Max Planck Institute of Quantum Optics
Germany

Prof. Jean Dalibard
Laboratoire Kastler Brossel
France

Prof. Luiz Davidovich
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro and Texas A&M University
Brazil and USA

Dr. Sebastian Deffner
Associate Professor UMBC
USA

Prof. David DeMille
Professor of Physics University of Chicago
USA

Dr. Oliver Dial
CTO - IBM Quantum
USA

Dr. Felix Christian Effenberger
Ernst Struengmann Institute
Germany

Prof. Artur Ekert
Oxford University
UK

Dr. Luca Galantucci
Researcher
Istituto per le Applicazioni del Calcolo, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (IAC-CNR Roma)
Italy

Prof. Steven M. Girvin
Eugene Higgins Professor of Physics Yale Quantum Institute
USA

Prof. Dr Susana Huelga
Ulm University
Germany

Prof. Randall G. Hulet
Fayez Sarofim Professor of Physics Rice University
USA

Mr. William Hurley
Founder and CEO Strangeworks
USA

Prof. Massimo Inguscio
Professor, Università Campus Biomedico di Roma
Italy

Prof. Kees Joosse
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Director Business Development EMEA
The Netherlands

Dr. Christophe Jurczak
CEO, Quantonation
France

Prof. Daniel Kleppner
Professor emeritus
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
USA

Dr. Antia Lamas-Linares
Principal Research Scientist Amazon
USA

Prof. Dr. Maciej Lewenstein
Group Leader ICFO and ICREA
Spain

Prof. Mikhail Lukin
Harvard University
USA

Prof. Dr. Eric Lutz
Director of the Institute for Theoretical Physics I University of Stuttgart
Germany

Dr. Lucas Madeira
Researcher
University of São Paolo
Brazil

Dr. John M. Martinis
Professor of Physics
University of California, Santa Barbara
USA

Prof. Christopher R. Monroe
Professor
Duke University
USA

Dr. Svetlana Monroe
Professor
Duke University
USA

Prof. Cristiane Morais Smith
Professor
Utrecht University, ITP
The Netherlands

Prof. Paulo Nussenzvieg
Professor
University of Sao Paulo
Brazil

Prof. José N. Onuchic
PAS Academician Professor
Rice University
USA

Lady Abigail Oppong
Independent Researcher
Ghana

Prof. Luis A. Orozco
Emeritus Professor
JQI, Physics, University of Maryland and NIST
USA

Prof. Dr. Tilman Pfau
Institute Director University of Stuttgart
Germany

Dr. William D. Phillips
PAS Academician JQI Fellow
Joint Quantum Institute
USA

Prof. Dr. Martin B. Plenio
Ulm University
Germany

Prof. Eugene S. Polzik
Professor
University of Copenhagen
Denmark

Dr. Robert Schoelkopf
Professor
Yale University
USA

Prof. Marlan O. Scully
Director in Institute for Quantum Science and Engineering Texas A&M University
USA

Prof. Irfan Siddiqi
Professor and Chair, Department of Physics UC Berkeley
USA

M.Sc. Laurent Simons
PhD Student
University of Antwerp
Belgium

Prof. Wolf Joachim Singer
PAS Academician
Senior Fellow, Ernst Struengmann Institute for Neuroscience
Germany

Prof. Andrew Steane
Professor of Physics
University of Oxford
UK

Prof. Donna Strickland
PAS Academician Professor
University of Waterloo
Canada

Prof. Sandro Stringari
Professor
University of Trento
Italy

Dr. Robert Sutor
Vice President and Chief Quantum Advocate Infleqtion
USA

Dr. Matthias Troyer
CVP, Technical Fellow Microsoft
USA

Prof. Daniel Varela Magalhães
Professor
Universidade de São Paulo
Brazil

Prof. Salvador E. Venegas-Andraca
Professor
Tecnológico de Monterrey
Mexico

Msgr. Dario E. Viganò
Vice Chancellor
The Pontifical Academy of Sciences
The Vatican

Celso Jorge Villas Boas
Full Professor
Federal University of São Carlos
Brazil

Prof. Dr. Klaus von Klitzing
PAS Academician Director Emeritus
Max Planck Institute for Solid State Research
Germany

Dr. Carl Williams
Principal
CJW Quantum Consulting LLC
USA

Prof. Vladislav Yakovlev
University Professor Texas A&M University
USA

Dr. Jun Ye
Physicist
NIST/JILA/University of Colorado
USA

Prof. Dr. Peter Zoller
Professor/Group Leader University of Innsbruck and IQOQI (Austrian Academy of Sciences)
Austria

Prof. Martin Zwierlein
Professor of Physics
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
USA